For ramblings on how I came to compile this list go here. And for commentary on previous selections: [#50-46] [#45-41] [#40-36] [#35-31] [#30-26] [#25-21] [#20-16] [#15-11] [#10-6]
Drum roll please....
5. Illinoise - Sufjan Stevens (2005)
Forget about simply putting out a concept album, Sufjan Stevens actually had the nerve to attempt a concept series. It appears that the fifty states, fifty albums project was most likely abandoned after this one, the second in the series, but when you've reached a pinnacle such as this, why continue? If I were to simply pick up this album without any prior knowledge, it would likely have been returned to the pile without even listening. Everything from the length of the song titles, (one song title is 53 words long) to the length of the album itself (clocking it at just under 75 minutes) would normally be too daunting a task for even one as ambitious as myself to undertake. But the hype eventually got to me, and boy, am I glad that this time, for once, the hype was right! This highly melodic history lesson of sorts has the feel of an epic movie, with all of the ingredients in tact. There's action, humor, moments that pull on the heartstrings as well as moments that make you think, not to mention villains that you boo and heroes that you cheer for. Mr. Stevens is one gifted individual, as is showcased by the fact that he can take some of the wordiest lyrics I've ever read, and combine these poetic puzzles to some of the hookiest musical accompaniment I've ever heard. There are some prize worthy melodies on this one: Decatur, Casimir Pulaski Day and the current king of road trip classics Chicago, to name a few. And the fact that the whole thing ends with such an amazing instrumental number called Out Of Egypt, Into The Great Laugh of Mankind and I Shake The Dirt From My Sandals As I Run that plays like a sonic stew of BSS, Peter Gabriel and The Mothers of Invention is like the perfect reward for sitting up and committing yourself to such an awesome album. [Myspace: Sufjan Stevens]
4. Black Sheep Boy - Okkervil River (2005)
While we're still in the vein of the highly ambitious, taking a classic Tim Hardin folk song and expanding on the song's theme by creating a full length concept album around it, would certainly fall in that category, and only the literary mind of Will Scheff would ever be able to pull that off. Normally, I'm a big believer that for a good lyrical album to work, it should be just as easy to enjoy whether one is paying attention to the lyrics or not. But this album is sort of the exception to that rule. Not that the album isn't good if you're not paying attention to the words and themes, but you really need to have the lyric sheet in front of you if you're going to be dropping this album in at number 4 on a 'best of the decade' list. The album touches on feelings of isolation and loneliness in a way that we can all relate to, no matter how popular we are (or think we are.) His ability to wax poetically while still maintaining candor and frankness cannot be an easy job, but this is exactly what he does throughout the course of the album, proving just how talented a songwriter he is. The fact that he does this so effectively makes it the type of album that can really speaks to me as I listen, to the point where I can actually see myself in the narrative. And those moments where the guitars literally blast out of the speakers are just an added bonus. [Myspace: Okkervil River]
3. The Trials Of Van Occupanther - Midlake (2006)
The opening piano notes of Roscoe are like a giant magnet that draws me in every time that I put this one on. In fact, whenever the song comes up on shuffle, it doesn't take long for me to shut off the shuffle feature and just let the album play, because you don't just listen to Roscoe and not let the rest of the album continue. That's like watching the opening scroll of Star Wars and then turning the channel. You just don't do it! The classic 70's sound of this album is an unabashed throwback, but it works so well that you just have to go with it. The album has a real earthy vibe to it, and when Tim Smith's understated vocals come in, accompanied by one of the strongest rhythm sections of the moment, I can almost smell the burning wood of a campfire, and feel the cool breeze off of the ocean. With acoustic guitars and flutes that chime like the earlier folksier output of Jethro Tull to the layered bassline and guitar backdrops that play like early to mid 70's period Fleetwood Mac, this album is sharp in beauty and rich in melody. The biggest secret to the album's success is the band's sense of control. Some of the instrumental moments at the end of the songs Head Home and We Gathered In Spring, show that the band is quite capable of bombarding us with grand progressive moments or over indulgent jam band adventures, while the vocals in songs like Young Bride and In This Camp show that Smith could probably sing the phone book if he wanted to, but the band chooses to keep things simple and accessible. Within the confines of The Trials of Van Occupanther, that approach works to their advantage and the album never overstays its welcome. [Myspace: Midlake]
2. Yankee Hotel Foxtrot - Wilco (2002)
We've all heard the story surrounding this album, making it the greatest success story in the history of indie music, as well as the defining moment when the record labels lost all credibility. But the whole adventure would not have gelled so effectively if the music on this album was not as good as it claimed to be, and the fact is, that even when listening to the album 7 years on, it's still an intoxicating beauty. The fact that all of the members of the band had the guts to take a collection of songs that would have worked just fine as subtle slices of alt-country fare, and expand them into sonically challenging art rock collages is an inspired move, and one that paid off in spades. I Am Trying To Break Your Heart is almost tear jerking, and that's amazing when you consider that the beat changes several times throughout the song, it's enshrouded in white noise and the lyrics don't really make any sense to me. There are other moments of expansive brilliance like the two songs that close the album, namely Poor Places and Reservations. Both of those songs contain atmospheric codas that, if left in lesser hands, would render the skip button necessary. Instead, they both dare you to keep listening and I don't know anyone who hasn't enjoyed the payoff that comes from doing so. Finally, to the staff of Reprise Records who claimed that the album wasn't commercial enough, I've got to know if they were even listening to tracks like I'm The Man Who Loves You, Pot Kettle Black, Heavy Metal Drummer or Jesus, Etc. because those are four of the greatest pop songs of all time, and they're all on the same album. If that doesn't equal record sales, than I don't know what does. The fact that this became Wilco's best selling album proves that they were wrong, we were right, and from that day on, this is my second favorite album of the decade and who needs them? [Myspace: Wilco]
1. You Forgot It In People - Broken Social Scene (2002)
If you follow this blog at all, then you already knew that this album had to be my number one! When I first heard it, (which incidentally was the day after I first saw them perform live) it single handedly restored my faith in the artistry of music. I had grown up listening to artists that were determined to strive beyond existing stagnant music forms, beginning that education with progressive rock, and then moving towards punk, new wave, 80's college radio and the beginnings of grunge, when suddenly, in the mid 90's I just got tired of it all. By the end of the decade, all I wanted was a good hook and a catchy pop style. That all changed when I saw Broken Social Scene play live and the celebratory nature of art rock was reawakened in me. There were something like 17 people on that stage, playing some songs that would be considered pop and other songs that would be considered avant garde. Some of the songs followed a verse chorus verse chorus format, while others were just the repeating of the same line over and over again, while yet other songs were instrumental blasts of horns and feedback. The band worked together like a well oiled machine, while each individual was contentedly admiring the talents of the guy or girl beside them and looking genuinely surprised at what was unfolding around them. What I saw on that stage was not just a band uniformly playing a collection of songs, it was a community of people that loved music and wanted not only to impress each other, but to be impressed by each other. And when I picked up this album and popped it into my CD player, the band actually managed to accomplish the seemingly impossible by transposing that energy and camaraderie to a physical disc. In my teens, I used to listen to albums repeatedly, to the point where I knew every snap crackle and pop that the cassette shot forth. By the time I hit my 20's however, those days were seemingly gone, both due to life getting in the way, and just general ADD. Again, that all changed with this album. I listened to it non stop for a couple of months, and then pulled it out weekly for a couple of years after that. It had been ages since an album had that kind of staying power for me then, and it hasn't happened for me since. There were undeniably better albums released this decade in a technical sense, but for me, where I was at the time it was released, where I was at the time that I picked it up, and where I am now, there really is no other album that comes close. This is my album. This is the one that originally motivated me to start blogging about music. This is the one that originally reawakened my desire for live music. This is the one that caused me to ignite a fire for what is going on locally. Yes, this is my favorite album of the decade. End. Gush. Now. [Myspace: Broken Social Scene]
Bobby B's 50 Albums Of The Decade Are:
1. You Forgot It In People - Broken Social Scene (2002)
2. Yankee Hotel Foxtrot - Wilco (2002)
3. The Trials of Van Occupanther - Midlake (2006)
4, Black Sheep Boy - Okkervil River (2005)
5. Illinoise - Sufjan Stevens (2005)
6. Third - Portishead (2008)
7. Man Made - Teenage Fanclub (2005)
8. Sebastopol - Jay Farrar (2001)
9. The Hazards Of Love - The Decemberists (2009)
10. Sorry Love - Pipas (2006)
11. Broken Social Scene - Broken Social Scene (2005)
12. Set Yourself On Fire - Stars (2004)
13. Smile - Brian Wilson (2004)
14. Lifted, Or The Story Is In The Soil, Keep Your Ear To The Ground - Bright Eyes (2002)
15. The Stage Names - Okkervil River (2007)
16. Love Is Hell - Ryan Adams (2004)
17. Let's Get Out Of This Country - Camera Obscura (2006)
18. I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning - Bright Eyes (2005)
19. The Crane Wife - The Decemberists (2006)
20. Gang Of Losers - The Dears (2006)
21. Boxer - The National (2007)
22. Funeral - Arcade Fire (2004)
23. Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots - The Flaming Lips (2002)
24. Destroyer's Rubies - Destroyer (2006)
25. Kid A - Radiohead (2000)
26. Let It Die - Feist (2004)
27. Fox Confessor Brings The Flood - Neko Case (2006)
28. Cryptograms - Deerhunter (2007)
29. Desperate Hearts, Blood Thirsty Babes - TV On The Radio (2004)
30. Heartbreaker - Ryan Adams (2000)
31. Figure 8 - Elliott Smith (2000)
32. A Ghost Is Born - Wilco (2004)
33. Glissandro 70 - Glissandro 70 (2006)
34. Hometowns - Rural Alberta Advantage (2008)
35. Ys - Joanna Newsom (2006)
36. Welcome Interstate Managers - Fountains of Wayne (2003)
37. You Are Free - Cat Power (2003)
38. For Emma, Forever Ago - Bon Iver (2008)
39. Icky Thump - White Stripes (2007)
40. Goodbye Doris - Fox Jaws (2007)
41. The Revolution Starts...Now - Steve Earle (2004)
42. And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out - Yo La Tengo (2000)
43. Is This It- The Strokes (2001)
44. Sunset Tree - The Mountain Goats (2005)
45. The Weekend - The Weekend (2000)
46. Left And Leavng - The Weakerthans (2000)
47. Never Hear The End Of It - Sloan (2006)
48. Writer's Block - Peter Bjorn And John (2006)
49. Everything I've Forgotten To Forget - Amos The Transparent (2007)
50. Gold - Ryan Adams (2001)
Labels: broken social scene, midlake, okkervil river, sufjan stevens, top 50 albums of the decade, wilco