The Weakerthans, Constantines and Waking Eyes @ The Phoenix
Ahhh, The Weakerthans. Most of you readers are well aware that seeing this Canadian treasure live has really been a long time coming and I'm glad to say that the wait is finally over. So was it worth it? Answer: a resounding yes! But let's start from the start...
The Waking Eyes put on a show that was not all that dissimilar to the one that I saw at Lee's Palace in March. The variety contained in their recorded material allows them to showcase their many layers on the live stage as well. The musicianship of this band is so incredibly adept that things continue to keep moving at a steady clip, while their creativity continues to shine through. Rusty Matyas and Matt Peters proved themselves to be very captivating frontmen, as they switched off instruments regularly throughout the set. Meanwhile, Steve Senkiw is obviously a more than capable drummer. Once again though, I wholeheartedly maintain that Joey Penner is a bass player extraordinaire and the greatest selling point of the band. It's hard to pinpoint exactly what it is that makes this guy impossible to ignore onstage, other than the fact that he's just a wizard of a bassist. Of course the entire band is solid, and even though the two acts to follow are regarded as a couple of Canada's best, The Waking Eyes easily held their own.
Photos: The Waking Eyes @ The Phoenix on flickr
Myspace: The Waking Eyes
Constantines have been declared by many to be the best live rock act that Canada has to offer. When I saw them perform at Toronto Island several years ago, I was pretty much ready to jump on that bandwagon myself. Well, absence makes the heart grow fonder as they say, and I was really looking forward to catching their live show again. There is no doubt that this band is an absolute powerhouse on stage; a rock 'n roll assault that makes you exhausted just looking at them. However, I've consistently felt that each successive album that they've released has showcased a band quickly running out of ideas, and unfortunately this was reflected in their live show also. For the most part, it was the older numbers that sounded great, while the newer ones just kinda lagged for me. The show opened strong enough, particularly when they pulled out Young Offenders, which was the second song of the night. The song's immediacy was rampant, coming across as if they had written it only yesterday. The show ended even stronger, beginning with Nightime/Anytime (It's Alright) and Justice, both from their first two albums. This was followed by a ripping version of Shine A Light, also from the second album of the same name and they ended their set with an explosive chorus of Do What You Can Do from Kensington Heights. If the show was limited to these five or six performances, it would have been insane. My problem was with the weak part in the middle. They played for nearly an hour, and I'm afraid that great energy cannot override mundane material, and sadly, the mind couldn't help but wander throughout the middle portion of the show. Personally, I was finding it very difficult to match their enthusiasm as each song started to sound the same. I've scanned the internet to try to find another poor review of a Constantines live show and I couldn't, so I'm willing to acknowledge that this is obviously more personal opinion than anything else. However, as a semi-jaded concert goer who remarkably still has the ability to be impressed often, I'm afraid this show only half did it for me. I will say that Bryan Webb does have an amazing voice though.
Photos: Constantines @ The Phoenix on flickr
Myspace: Constantines
All of my concerns with Constantines set can apply in an opposite way to The Weakerthans. In comparison to the two bands that preceded them, energy and power are not two words that you'll read in any live review about our favourite Winnipegers. The comment has been made that when it comes to seeing The Weakerthans live, you may as well just stay home and listen to the records. I suppose that in many ways, this is a valid point. However, one cannot underestimate the power of the material. The Weakerthans are a true Canadian treaure for a reason. They've written some of the greatest lyrics in Can-Rock history, and Aside is one of my favourite songs of all time. Anywhere. So on the strength of the songs alone, there was no way that this show was not going to be anything short of overwhelmingly pleasurable. It's true, their show does not come with any flashes of light, or acrobatics performed by the Cirque de Soleil, but when you're showcasing songs like Left And Leaving, Virtue The Cat and Reconstruction Site, gimmicks no longer become necessary. John K. Samson simply walks on stage, smiles and performs the songs, and from what I could judge by the audience's reaction, nothing else was needed. Speaking about audience reaction, let's talk a little bit about the audience. This was another one in a series of dreaded all ages shows that I've been attending recently, and I wouldn't be me if I didn't moan a little bit about how much I hate all ages shows. If you're not interested in another self indulgent rant, feel free to skip ahead to paragraph three.
As far as all ages shows go, this was not the worst one that I've been to. Unlike the Born Ruffians show I attended last year, or the Broken Social Scene show that I attended shortly thereafter, or The Hives show prior to that, for the most part the young 'uns managed not to get all up in my peace, so I was pretty grateful for that. Still, I could've easily done without the gaggle of horribly tone deaf female teenster singalongs that accompanied every single syllable emanating from Samson's mouth that night. If you want everyone to listen to your overwhelmingly bad prepubescent cackle, then go and form your own band and see if you can sell out three nights at the Phoenix on your own. Basically I doubt it, what with your voices sucking and everything. (Oooh, that was offside 'eh? Hehe, I'm a jerk sometimes...)
And now back to our regularly scheduled review. Some of my favourite moments, besides hearing Aside, came during the encore, which began with Samson returning to the stage solo, and performing One Great City! Admittedly there was something slightly sinister about a crowd screaming "I Hate Winnipeg!" at the top of their lungs, but you couldn't wipe the smile off of my face if you tried. One fan had been screaming for My Favourite Chords since the show began, so one can only imagine the elation he must have felt when they pulled that one out and performed it in such a beautifully introspective way. And finally, their Casio heavy rendition of Anchorless was amazing, with only the drummer being unequipped with the instrument. Samson claimed that they were not planning on doing this song and it was only by request that they pulled it out, but they seem to have been doing it all tour, so I'm not sure if I believe him. Either way, it sounded great.
The Weakerthans will always be the definition of a perfect band to me. The combination of marvelously poetic lyricism, hooky melodies and warmly endearing stage presence is what makes them truly great, and hopefully the opportunity I've had to finally catch their live show will not simply end here.
Photos: The Weakerthans @ The Phoenix on flickr
Myspace: The Weakerthans
Labels: concert review, constantines, the phoenix, waking eyes, weakerthans



